GaryDean:
I started with 18 Basque eggs from Skyline (16 hatched) and 5 chicks from GFF. None of them had willow legs. Guess I just got lucky. I had millefleur, white legs, blondies and a heterozygous barred rooster. Out of all those chickens I ended up with a breeding trio.
Ashdoes:
There is nothing wrong with raising chickens for fun but if you want to standardize, show and/or improve a breed you have to do the numbers. A master breeder told me the average # of chicks you have to raise to get one good one is a dozen. So to get a decent trio you may need to raise 36 or more chicks and cull the rest (either move to a layer flock, sell and/or slaughter.) That is also assuming you start with good foundation stock.
DCchicken:
There are people who do make money at chickens simply because there are people with more money than sense. While I understand that GFF invests quite a bit of money and effort in importing rare breeds that can justify what they charge, they only get it because there are folks willing to pay it. Then there are the Martha Stewart and P. Allen Smith types whom people follow. I'm sure you've seen people willing to pay high prices for "rare" (unrecognized) colors or English, German or French lines of one breed or another too. I don't know how some sellers can sleep at night. Personally, I don't believe I'll ever do more than make enough money to support my chicken habit
(feed, pens, dues and the occasional show) at least that's my goal.
The rest of us have our limits which vary. While I was willing to shell out $99 per chick for a pair of CLs in late 2011 it was because I liked the breed and it was a Christmas present (as crazy as the hubby thought I was). GFF was nice enough to send an extra pullet chick so it didn't turn out to be quite so much, but there is no way I would pay $2K or more for a pair of chickens! Obviously there are those who will and have. As for my earlier comment, there are plenty of PT Barnum type folks out there who are willing to make an investment early on and ride the wave of supply/demand to make a quick buck. Just look at Alpacas. No one eats them, there really isn't a significant market for the fleeces, you can't ride them and they need a guardian (llamma or LGD) but for awhile everyone was spending tens of thousands of dollars for each just to breed and sell to others down the line. The "market" eventually bottomed out but those who got in early made ridiculous amounts of money.
Generally:
As for bloodlines, I'm of two minds on this. The bloodline i.e. genetics are the same as long as no outcrossing occurs so in that sense it is one line. However, I also agree that the breeding decisions made down the line skew the type/color/production qualities in one direction or another with may or may not match those of the original breeder. I generally tell people where my foundation stock came from and if lines have been crossed. Five years seems to be the point at which one continues as serious breeder or quits the field. If I am still working with a line at that point and my stock is different from it's foundation, then it is my line.
Just my 2 cents.