@JudysMuscovy That is a hard question to answer:
What will your girls bring to the mix?
What are your goals? Cream or Crele?
You can never say which rooster to use without seeing the girls, Some times the girls each need a different rooster. Last year I used 3 roosters. It worked out well, I hope to be at 2 next year.
You will need a stronger combed girl to straighten the comb out. The body on the second, from what the pictures shows has the better body, the first one has a little more cream to it ...of course all in my Humble Opinion..