Leslie, I remove spurs before breeding. I was told that spurs can injure or even kill a hen.
Agreed, Kim. It's a question of timing ... the size & shape of the spur compared to breeding season.
Last year I did not remove spurs on my male Delaware, but they were tiny. Just after I started collecting eggs to hatch, one of my two breeding females got a pretty serious breeding injury on her side and we are certain that was from a toenail, not a spur. She doesn't have the best feather quality (too loose and fluffy, IMO, prone to frizzing), so I'm thinking that's part of why her side got torn. With a denim saddle the wound healed.
This year PapaDel's spurs are certainly larger, but still not pointy. With the size & weight of this breed, the pressure of the spur still might cause a tear, especially with an uncooperative female, so we were thinking of dealing with that now. If we pull the spurs off, there is a small chance of him getting an infection, so I need to weigh that risk when I decide what to do. We could always trim & file his spurs for now ... if trimmed and filed properly that should help a lot ... and then I could remove the spurs after he's put back on vacation. It seems easier to just pop them off. So I have to consider pros and cons of both options.
This year's F5 cockerels still have tiny smooth spurs ... I think I'll leave them be for this year.
Meanwhile, I have the spurs on some of the males in the hatchery egg flock to deal with.
I still need to get you photos of my "spare" cockerels so you can decide if you think it's worth it to try to get one to you. You have some really nice females (better than mine, I'm sure), so it would be great if you had choices for making breeding pens next year. What kinds of qualities are you looking for in a breeding cockerel to compliment your females? Yellow legs for one thing? That way I can try to capture those things in the photos. Between me and Zanna maybe we have something useful for you, if you're looking for something this year.