ohiofarmgirl - I completely agree and have been working with my dog in a similar fashion!
As for which breed of dog is best with chickens, I feel that it really depends on the dog as an individual, their training/how they have been brought up and accustomed to, and their overall respect for their owner's possessions; however, more 'guardian' breeds such as the Great Pyrenees, Bernese Mountain Dog, Sheep Dog, some breeds of shepherds, etc seem to do well with flocks.
I use to have a little maltese who was quite the character. She would leave the chickens alone unless instructed to "get them" in which she would round them up back into they coop (I wish the commend was a different set of word, but that worked for her).
Now, I have a Carolina Dog/Dixie Dingo. She's actually a shelter rescue and needed quite a bit of work in over coming her nervous issues. Since the breed is still quite feral and has a strong prey drive, I wouldn't expect it to be very good with chickens, but Sabina seems to be proving me wrong. Occasionally she gets excited and playful and tends to bull-doze through the flock to which she gets a "No! Leave them!" and then she shamefully backs away immediately and then all is fine. I've never seen her actually go after the chickens in terms of wanting to kill them, but I still feel it's better off to correct any behavior of that sort [not commanded of the dog] before the dog begins to think they can get away with more and more intense versions of "the game." She is quite funny though and sometimes brings her toys to our chickens to see if they would like to play with her. As for squirrels, rabbits, rats, and birds - that's a whole different issue.... but chickens, she's been pretty good with; however, I still feel that more 'wild' breeds of dog wouldn't be well suited as a chicken dog and that the Carolina Dog isn't quite a good flock/small animal guardian as a breed in whole.
As for which breed of dog is best with chickens, I feel that it really depends on the dog as an individual, their training/how they have been brought up and accustomed to, and their overall respect for their owner's possessions; however, more 'guardian' breeds such as the Great Pyrenees, Bernese Mountain Dog, Sheep Dog, some breeds of shepherds, etc seem to do well with flocks.
I use to have a little maltese who was quite the character. She would leave the chickens alone unless instructed to "get them" in which she would round them up back into they coop (I wish the commend was a different set of word, but that worked for her).
Now, I have a Carolina Dog/Dixie Dingo. She's actually a shelter rescue and needed quite a bit of work in over coming her nervous issues. Since the breed is still quite feral and has a strong prey drive, I wouldn't expect it to be very good with chickens, but Sabina seems to be proving me wrong. Occasionally she gets excited and playful and tends to bull-doze through the flock to which she gets a "No! Leave them!" and then she shamefully backs away immediately and then all is fine. I've never seen her actually go after the chickens in terms of wanting to kill them, but I still feel it's better off to correct any behavior of that sort [not commanded of the dog] before the dog begins to think they can get away with more and more intense versions of "the game." She is quite funny though and sometimes brings her toys to our chickens to see if they would like to play with her. As for squirrels, rabbits, rats, and birds - that's a whole different issue.... but chickens, she's been pretty good with; however, I still feel that more 'wild' breeds of dog wouldn't be well suited as a chicken dog and that the Carolina Dog isn't quite a good flock/small animal guardian as a breed in whole.