After losing prolific egg-layer breeds to shorter lifespans we switched from popular egg-layer breeds to hens with reputations for less eggs, have broody tendency, and with sweeter temperaments -- tops for us after a dozen years of basckyarding are:
DOMINIQUES
BEARDED SILKIES
BREDA (unfortunately this breed turned out not hardy and sort of phased out)
Doms are Cuckoo-patterned, typically mid-size averaging 5-lbs, laying small-med eggs
Bearded Silkies come in many color patterns, a larger bantam, 2 to 2.5-lbs, small eggs
Breda's are one of our favorite breeds for temperament but have a small gene pool & not hardy, around 5 lbs, small-med eggs, come in blue/black/splash, mottled, or cuckoo pattern.
Our Blue Breda is outside the pen w/ Cuckoo Breda inside pen. Breda have heavily feathered legs, vulture hocks, no comb, triangle crest on head - beautiful birds but genetics cause health problems and extremely difficult to find them now.