Since we only have 3 hens (and just started with chickens last Spring), we don't have enough extra eggs to share them far and wide. So we hadn't run into many strange comments. Our parents and neighbors love when we can share and know that they are especially good.
When visiting my parents over Christmas, we brought all the eggs we could, as my sister and her family were there too. My husband was talking to my brother-in-law about them and said they were the freshest, best tasting eggs he'd ever eat.
My BIL said "My eggs are white and come from the store, a dozen to a carton!"
DH tried, and said "Store eggs are weeks old when you get them. These are fresh, days old at most and our chickens are well cared for, healthy, and eat good feed." (he didn't mention the tasty bugs and weeds!)
BIL just made a face (like someone suggested eating something gross) and said not for him.
I was surprised and now wonder what my sister thinks! Since they live far away, we only see them a couple times a year and pretty much never at our house. So they haven't seen the chickens in person yet. I'm sure they think we're really weird!