Sadly D&B Supply also sold me "Auracanas" and "Americanas" when they were really Easter Eggers. They also sold us two roos when they were to be pullets. So, our first set we ended up with an EE who lays pink eggs and has no tail (see picture). She is stunning and a bit goofy. Her feathers are so dark that you cant see her eyes so I've nicknames our beloved Anne Bolyn, Miss Maggoo. LOL
These were our first chickens and I've learned my lesson: buy from a reputable company/hatchery NOT the local farm supply store.
Ann Bolyn "Miss Magoo" is lovely and adorable even though she was sold as an Araucana -- she IS tail-less but the muffed cheeks give her away as not being a pure Araucana since Araucana are tufted rather than muffed. I know feed stores mis-label their chickens as whatever the hatchery called them when bought. I guess the misnomer for Easter Eggers, Ameraucanas, and Araucanas will continue for more decades to come as long as hatcheries, feed stores, and private breeders sell off their birds as other than what they truly are. Since the 1970's many hatcheries refuse to identify the differences when selling today but recently many more reputable hatcheries are delineating the differences when selling EEs vs Ameraucanas vs Araucanas. It's still up to the customer to research the differences before finalizing a purchase. Miss Magoo is a very unique and gorgeous bird. She is probably a very sweet hen too -- EEs as well as Amer's tend to be kind and non-combative toward flockmates which is why I prefer keeping them mixed with a timid flock rather than more assertive dual-purpose type breeds. Very nice girl!