Yes, you are exactly right! The one that lays the turquoise egg has slate colored legs and a peacomb. Those are two Ameraucana traits. My theory is, that the more "Ameraucana" traits you see, the greater your chances are at some sort of blue egg.
I do have 3 new EEs that are just about to lay. They all have peacombs, and very green legs. One of the EEs is white, the other two are a bright reddish buff. I am betting that I get green eggs from them. BUT, I am hoping for PINK!!!
I will post pics of the girls and their eggs as soon as they start laying. I just love the mystery-factor of EEs!!! I find the last few weeks leading up to lay are the most exciting!
I wonder if anyone out there has a pic of their EE that lays pink eggs? I would love to see!
I do have 3 new EEs that are just about to lay. They all have peacombs, and very green legs. One of the EEs is white, the other two are a bright reddish buff. I am betting that I get green eggs from them. BUT, I am hoping for PINK!!!

I wonder if anyone out there has a pic of their EE that lays pink eggs? I would love to see!