Can chickens lay different color of eggs? I have a Buff Orpington hen, Rose, and she lays a pretty dark brown eggs. I had to put a BO pullet in there yesterday and she should be laying already but hasn't yet, so this morning I was going to take J.T. ( Bo pullet ) back to the main coop and I found an egg. J.T. should already be laying, but hasn't layed one yet. So I don't know if Rose or J.T. layed that egg! The egg I found was a light brown egg with tiny white specks all over it! That's why I wonna know if a chicken can lay a dark colored egg, then lay a light brown egg with white specks??? Any advice would be great. Thanks!