If this were me and I was legal, when asked what I was gonna do about it I'd yell back " I am buying all the unwanted roosters on craislistHens can be louder then the roos when they get to screaming the egg song, sounds to me like if you got rid of your roos he'd find a problem with the hens. DO NOT give in to that Jerk! I feel for ya I walk on eggshells everyday being in a suburban neighborhood with free range chickens and a total of 5 roosters as well as being illegal. Fortunately the only ones who have a problem with my birds also have a problem with domestic disputes and drugs, the coppers are there at least a few times a week. Everyone else just absolutely loves them. Stand your ground as you have every right to.