Mmm...I do think that beards have to go into the first part of that "what makes a Fav a Fav" as well.
Yup, Your absolutely right about the beards, (they wouldn't be as endearing, vbg) but i came from a background history (not chickens) where some of the most important aspects and traits were left behind in the quest of what someones ideal show animal was to be even if it became contrary to what they were originally bred for...
When you're selecting your male, you also need to look at your females. What do you need to improve, or move forward, from where you are? Are the girls too dark? Then use the male with lighter coloring. Are the girls too small? Then use the larger male.
Something else you can do, especially since it would be a big help in the learning process, would be to use one male, mark or band all the chicks, then use the other male, and mark or band them differently. You'll see as the birds grow exactly what you'll get from each male, as long as you hatch enough chicks to give you a good representation.
Love the Mahog. Fav. Roo, He's gentle, and this morning one of the older babies (2 + months) kept hiding under his wing and he just stood there with his wing out....
BTW, Cloverleaf, acute liver failure was the final diagnosis.....possibly from the abundant buttercup thats hard to get rid of.
e