Fish emergency! - Never mind, resolved.

FreeChicken!

Songster
12 Years
Joined
Nov 14, 2010
Messages
215
Reaction score
4
Points
184
On Friday I bought two Golden Algae Eaters, and I did everything possible to make sure they settled into their home well. At first everything was fine, they got along perfectly with my male Betta, and they seemed quite happy and energetic.
But today I realized they've been ignoring their food, or at least one of them has. I'm not too concerned about the littler one, but the bigger one worries me a lot. It just "sits" in front of its food without eating, and has been swimming a little sideways. It's been turning pale too, and is no longer the bright orange it was when I bought it. It seems to have no energy too. Normally it can swim about ten inches in a split second when something frightens it, but today it barely even moved when I scooped it up to examine it.
This is worrying me a lot. Does anyone know what's wrong or what I can do?
 
How large is your tank?

What is your PH?

Ammonia levels?

Temperature?

Where did you purchase the fish?
 
20 gallons.
Unsure of the PH, planning on testing the water as soon as possible.
Someone told me that my ammonia levels are most likely quite high.
78 degrees F.
Countrymax.

I was just told that my ammonia levels are probably very high and oxygen levels low, and I need to get a filter. I'll try to get one this weekend. Meanwhile, I'll just have to do daily water changes.
 
20 gallons.
Unsure of the PH, planning on testing the water as soon as possible.
Someone told me that my ammonia levels are most likely quite high.
78 degrees F.
Countrymax.

I was just told that my ammonia levels are probably very high and oxygen levels low, and I need to get a filter. I'll try to get one this weekend. Meanwhile, I'll just have to do daily water changes.
How many other fish do you have and when was the last time you did a water change? I actually own and operate a planted aquarium business and have been involved with fish keeping and breeding since 1978. Generally speaking, when a person buys "algae eating fish" because they have a need for them, it means they are not doing enough water changes. Regardless of your issue, the solution to pollution is dilution. Stop feeding your fish for the next week or so, they can go very long times without food in captivity and I generally recommend feeding every other day to my clients anyway. You are going to begin by doing a 1/3 water change every other day. Your PH is probably way off, however it is best to make changes gradually and the water changes will soon eliminate the problems if done correctly. Make sure to use a gravel vacuum to remove any fuzzy food embedded in the gravel, and try to do a different section each day. Keep this regimen up until 9 water changes have been made, then re-test to see where you are.

You might have noticed I did not mention your filter in all of this. Regardless of filter type, this was deliberate. Your filter needs to remain "dirty" during this phase of your tank rehabilitation in order to preserve your bacterial balance, should it be cleaned you will possibly strip your tanks beneficial bacteria and cause a new tank syndrome to occur. New tank syndrome occurs when there is not enough beneficial bacteria present in a tank to perform the nitrogen cycle. This means ammonia and nitrite, both highly toxic, will need to spike, plateau, and recede prior to the tank becoming ecologically stable again- this is something to be avoided for the sake of the fish. Just stop feeding the fish (which only adds to the pollution at this point) do your water changes, remove any fish that do not make it (there might be some) and all should be well in about 2 weeks. There will probably be an algae bloom at some point when the toxic ammonia and Nitrite drop into levels that algae can thrive in- do not clean it as it will help speed the recovery of the aquarium. Adding a floating plant like duckweed will also speed the recovery, as they will remove toxins from the tank as the duckweed is removed, however I would not add any floating plants until water change number 4 or so, as they also can cause the oxygen levels to drop.

The algae eating species you bought, also known as "Chinese Algae Eater" Latin name is "Gyrinocheilus aymonieri", these fish are only going to eat algae until around 3 inches in size. At the end of their juvenile growth phase their mouth changes, slowly shifting toward the front of their face and they become carnivorous, eating slime and scales off of other fish. They top out around 10 inches in size when fully grown. It should be fine for a while, but you will want to trade it/them in when it hits 3 inches, preferably before it/them begins to damage fish. Personally I prefer snails for non-planted tanks, and otto cats for planted tanks to be algae maintenance. If algae gets to the point where you have troubles with the glass being clean you are not doing enough water changes and/or over feeding your fish. Buying a pleco or algae eater to "clean" a tank is sort of like buying a cow to mow a lawn, it is a very temporary fix at best, and BIG problems in the future at worst.

Hope this helps, best of luck to you
Sandi, owner of Cape Cod Aquascapes
 
Sorry I didn't respond to this sooner! I've been busy.
Unfortunately, both of my algae eaters died a few days ago. I still need to get a water testing kit to check the PH (I completely forgot when I went to the store to get a filter). I'm certainly going to be more careful from now on. When my tank is properly cycled, I'm planning on finding some ottos since I've been told they get along with Bettas--since I have one, a male. My Betta seemed friendly enough with the algae eaters while I had them, watching them from afar and ignoring them when he got close to them. So I'm sure he could mix well with other kinds of fish, though that remains to be seen.
I was afraid that all the changes in the water would harm my Betta, but luckily he seems okay. He's pretty energetic, swimming back and forth in front of his reflection and, when I feed him, chasing the bits of food that the filter's current pushes around. So I'm not too worried about him, but I'll keep a very close eye on him just in case.
Thank you for the information! I did a lot of studying about this stuff since my algae eaters got sick, though some of what you said was stuff I hasn't heard before. I will definitely jot this advice down.
 
Sorry I didn't respond to this sooner! I've been busy.
Unfortunately, both of my algae eaters died a few days ago. I still need to get a water testing kit to check the PH (I completely forgot when I went to the store to get a filter). I'm certainly going to be more careful from now on. When my tank is properly cycled, I'm planning on finding some ottos since I've been told they get along with Bettas--since I have one, a male. My Betta seemed friendly enough with the algae eaters while I had them, watching them from afar and ignoring them when he got close to them. So I'm sure he could mix well with other kinds of fish, though that remains to be seen.
I was afraid that all the changes in the water would harm my Betta, but luckily he seems okay. He's pretty energetic, swimming back and forth in front of his reflection and, when I feed him, chasing the bits of food that the filter's current pushes around. So I'm not too worried about him, but I'll keep a very close eye on him just in case.
Thank you for the information! I did a lot of studying about this stuff since my algae eaters got sick, though some of what you said was stuff I hasn't heard before. I will definitely jot this advice down.
hope all is well... be careful w/ ottos they are kinda delicate. Also bettas are territorial so moving things around when introducing new fish is a good idea to prevent hostility... think of it as turf confusion. You can also just put him in a jar on top of the tank for a couple of days, they literally live and breed in water filled hoof prints, puddles, shallow rice paddys, and ditches filled with water in their native home. I bred these for years as a kid, quite literally had hundreds of them in my bedroom in mayo, spagetti sauce, and mason jars.
 
Last edited:

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom