If money is no object, then I wouldn't mind keeping a favorite hen now and again. But, money is always an object here, so I have to be very practical about culling my flock. My chickens aren't a hobby or pets to me, so the choice is a little more clear.
Is it easier? Not really. I still feel some remorse when killing a nice, sweet hen who has followed me around for companionship. But, when it comes down to it, where would you draw the line?
I hated killing my older, good roo. He was a good, sweet ol' roo but I think he was shooting blanks and he was the dominant roo....so, if I want to raise my own offspring and I free range, what are my choices? Rehome? And not know if he is being treated well? I'd rather give him a quick and merciful death after giving him this wonderful life of safety and chicken fun.
I have a flock of 29 hens and a young roo now. If I let them all age naturally and live out their lives here, pretty soon I would be having a big feed liability and no dividends.
It's never simple and never easy. But then, no one promised life was going to be simple or easy. Some things just have to be done and you stiffen your spine and just
do it. The cradle of the killing cone and a sharp knife across the throat is swift and gives my old friends a good death. They are then turned into something useful. If they die of old age, what then would I use them for? Buzzard food?
Naw....I give them freedom, good food, a safe home and plenty of sunshine and fresh air. My old friends give me joy while they are alive and sustenance when they are dead. We should all be so lucky in our lives!