Maybe I can resurrect this thread ! I'll be trying to incubate (my first time incubating, hopefully will be my first chicken ever) a dozen whole foods eggs. They sell out really quickly, and they ship some more in EVERY MORNING... Really fresh. I'll be making a thread on my eggs, soon! I'm sure the people on the farm realize what fertile eggs are, people hatch them all the time. Maybe the people that incubated them got a bad laying date, or their incubator was off. And of course, some people will get eggs fresher. Like I said, WF told me they get fertile eggs shipped in daily. I live in Michigan, right next to Detroit. Other people (California, though they have TJ) might get them a bit later ! Like here, TJ doesn't have fertile eggs. Only WF.