I've got one like the one you have pictured in your first post. After using it for a week or so I gave up on it and bought another kind. It's a pain to flip upright after you fill it and keep from dumping it. The water comes to within 1/4" from the top of the dish so if it's not sitting pretty much level the water will run out and it'll empty itself and you're not suppose to hang it. My opinion is to get something else.