I think I'd choose someone I can't stand to be around for more than five minutes. It would give me incentive to get myself off the danged island. I think I'd take my neighbor Irene...she'd start a homeowners' association just so she could say I was violating the rules, she would find a way to call animal control when my monkey pooped near her hammock, and just generally complain about everything I did. To get away from her, I'd find a way off the island even if I have to swim 1000 miles.
Failing that, I'd take Les Stroud, because he can survive without a support team, or my 13 year-old son who has memorized every survival show he has ever seen or finally, my dh because after 25 years together, I know he can but up with me and on a deserted island we might just get some privacy.

Failing that, I'd take Les Stroud, because he can survive without a support team, or my 13 year-old son who has memorized every survival show he has ever seen or finally, my dh because after 25 years together, I know he can but up with me and on a deserted island we might just get some privacy.