Help... Wrong Chick in order... Identity Unknown

[Kat's Silly Chickens]

Oh this is Depressing, we picked up chicks and got home and here's our story...

Our order was suppose to be:
Bantam Sultan SR 1
Blue Silkie Bantam ST RUN 1
Buff Silkie Bantam ST RUN 1
Red Silkie Bantam ST RUN 1

I was under the impression that all Silkies have dark blue flesh and bones, blue earlobes, and five toes on each foot and feathered legs/feet.
1 of the chicks we received (and it was snuggled down in the corner of the box so we didn't notice) is definitely not a Silkie.

It has pinkish yellow beak and legs, and has only 4 toes no feathers on legs/feet.
We can't go all the way back down to hatchery to replace the chick which we have no idea what type it is suppose to be.
Pictured below are all the chicks separated.

Could someone help to identify the Unknown Chick???

Blue Silkie

Red Silkie??? or Buff Silkie??? Which am I also?

Sultan

Please help me Identify my Chicks...

Thank you,

 

[Rebel Rooster]

Wow... this would be tough at this point... there are so many little pink chick breeds, it would be almost impossible to know until the chick is fledged out...

 

[team edward]

is it a standard or a bantam?

 

[Kat's Silly Chickens]

It is a bantam I guess, it was suppose to be a bantam silkie, red or buff... The 3rd pic is a silkie but don't know if it is a red or buff, maybe if I can get that 1 identified I'll know what color the other 1 is.

Sorry I put this in the wrong forum heading...

 

[dieselgrl48]

Hard to say but it Is cute though.If it's a clean leg bantam most likely an OEGB.I love mine. Hope it turns out to be a nice bird anyway.They are All adorable.

 

[Kat's Silly Chickens]

I had to think a minute on the OEGB. Will have to look it up.
I'm still trying to figure out which the 3rd pic is, 1 of them is mine, and the other's my dads and we play/hold our chicks separately so they get use to each of it's owners.
So in order to figure out the 1st pic's owner it'll be best to identify the color of the 3rd bird.
I'm gonna be

if 1st pic is mine, my first pair of chicks were the wrong breed, and I ordered the Red Silkie cause I liked the color. I don't want a Buff colored chicken.

Thank you for pointing me in a direction.

 

[reesepoultry]

The silkie you have is a red silkie. So you are out your buff silkie.

Have no clue what breed the little one is.

 

[Kat's Silly Chickens]

Quote:
Oh, thank you...

My dad said if the light colored Silkie is the red 1, not to worry that the other isn't a Silkie, as long as me and mom got what we wanted.

If the 1st pic grows up to be buff colored he'll be happy, he jokingly named his Partridge Cochins Bar-B and Que and wanted to complete the sandwich with a cheese colored chicken.

I have been searching every Bantam breed to see if I can figure it out. I'll keep looking.
Thanks for your help

 

[reesepoultry]

Looks like you could have possibly gotten a Buff Old English Bantam chick.

here is a link to the picture of it as a chick: https://secuservices.com/ideal/newideal/selectproduct.aspx?qty=1&ID=BFOEB&Product=679

 

[Kat's Silly Chickens]

That's what I was thinking, but wasn't sure. If the girl that picked the order at least got a buff we'll be happy, but my dad wants some refund for it not being a Silkie. This is the 2nd time our order has had a mistake, but we have the number of chickens we want so that's what matters.
Thank you again reesepoultry