As I read different threads, the question needs to be asked, what is the difference?
Show birds are all about the physical type vs. standard. F.E., egg production, carcass qualities have no bearing here.
Commercial birds are all about the production side, F.E., egg production, livability, carcass qualities, etc, depending upon the birds use.
Heritage birds were bred (as I understand it) to be of commercial value for those in that area. I'm sure beauty in the sight of the breeder was also an influence. So if it looks the part but doesn't perform, is it the intended "heritage" breed? If it performs as intended but doesn't look like the old pictures is it no longer a "heritage" breed?
So what do you think the initial breeders were after--production or looks?
Of what value are top knots, 5th toes, beards, feathered shanks, etc? Why ask? I read many threads about the "looks" of heritage breeds but nothing about the production side. Since the production side is not selected for by hobby breeders (assuming no one lives off their income from poultry breeding), are they truly the "old heritage breed" or just a carbon likeness? Kind of like my bantams are to the standard size chicken?
Show birds are all about the physical type vs. standard. F.E., egg production, carcass qualities have no bearing here.
Commercial birds are all about the production side, F.E., egg production, livability, carcass qualities, etc, depending upon the birds use.
Heritage birds were bred (as I understand it) to be of commercial value for those in that area. I'm sure beauty in the sight of the breeder was also an influence. So if it looks the part but doesn't perform, is it the intended "heritage" breed? If it performs as intended but doesn't look like the old pictures is it no longer a "heritage" breed?
So what do you think the initial breeders were after--production or looks?
Of what value are top knots, 5th toes, beards, feathered shanks, etc? Why ask? I read many threads about the "looks" of heritage breeds but nothing about the production side. Since the production side is not selected for by hobby breeders (assuming no one lives off their income from poultry breeding), are they truly the "old heritage breed" or just a carbon likeness? Kind of like my bantams are to the standard size chicken?