Hornswaggled! Is this an Easter Egger?

[BeeSpice]

Awhile ago I bought a hen from someone and he said it was a Whiting True Blue. She is clearly not. She lays a light pink speckled egg. A few days ago I bought another hen that looks IDENTICAL in every single way, even the egg size. She lays a bright teal egg. She is an Easter Egger. Is it safe to assume the first bird I bought is an Easter Egger too? Any opinions either way are appreciated. First picture is the new EE and last picture is the girl in question…

 

[nuthatched]

any mixed breed bird that has the possibility of laying a blue or green egg is an Easter egger.

 

[RoostersAreAwesome]

Both are Easter eggers, they don’t always lay colored eggs

 

[Percheron chick]

Sure. Pink is an EE egg color.

 

[Chipmunk Chicks]

Sure. Pink is an EE egg color.

Especially Pink with speckles.

 

[BeeSpice]

Especially Pink with speckles.

That’s what I was researching too. It is clearly not any of the breeds that lay a pink speckled egg