We are considering rehoming (though you can't ever know what the end result will be for them, so not my first choice), and we have also tossed around the idea of an island in our pond. This is our first year raising chickens and ducks, which is why I posted to this thread asking for suggestions and what realistic expectations could be. Thank you to those that have tried to give me ideas and suggestions.
A couple of you've been a little harsh though. Someone referenced the catalog picture that I posted , but I am not reading it the way they did . It says "true to their habit as migratory birds, these birds will fly".. the updated online catalog even adds after that sentence "away for the winter, but will often return to the same location in the spring." I don't want for them to starve, and I don't mind if they stay on our pond and property. In fact, that was my intention all along, that they could stay if they liked but that it wouldn't break my heart if they left. And in taking them on as my responsibility, this was my expectation. What I need them to leave from is my pen. When they are put up overnight and then till I let them out in the morning, unlike a large outdoor pond and yard area, in the pen the male pekin just doesn't have anywhere to go to get away from them. Every day since they've been old enough, they have gone down to the pond and foraged until sunset. They actually take very little food while in the pen, but they are in the habit of coming back to it at night with the others. So again, I was here looking for solutions, not to be called irresponsible or cruel.