OK lets help each other and the others can help us too! Lets list the options and see what everyone thinks.
My aim is to breed some easter eggers so at least one of my decisions is easy! I'm in the same situation - I need to only have 1 or at the most 2. Spring seems to have really put chilli down thier pants and the girls getting run ragged! I have the following:
- William - a pure white araucana - he is staying for his blue egg genes!
- King Louis - a mix of not 100% sure - Orpington / Pekin I think. He was my first roo that I knew of and he is really lovely looking and lovely so I feel awful culling BUT I think I shoudl really as he is already a mix!
- Blue Copper Marans roo - was going to cull as soon as I knew but then started thinking about the dark egg genes over my different coloured girls so he has moved to a maybe

- A HUGE grey orpington - he is lovely and gorgeous but I don't think the orps are a good feed / egg ratio to be honest. I do have to finish getting rid of his scaley mites and if I did that I'm sure I could sell him as they are rare here but I'm thinking maybe the pot realistically!
- A tiny little cochin bantam with a quite irritating crow! Doesn't eat much and is quite cute. I've just moved my 2 silkies into the broody / babies run as I decided they were terrified and not leaving the coop for weeks (thought it was rain to start with but then carried on and I think it is the grey Orp' roo as he seemed to really go at them the second they came down). I wondered if it would be worth a try putting him in with them?
That's it but really need to get rid of them as they are bickering as well as really going mad at the girls.