Well, here's my take on it. I don't like them being knocked around by the hatched chicks. I also don't like the carton method either. I have had less than stellar results with it. some chicks do pip the wrong end, Also, if they just pip a little bit low on the shell, say midway, there is still a good chance that they can get a mouthful of goop and choke out. It is also a very difficult position for them to climb up out of. In nature, ther are hatched on their sides, but mother hen, and the depressed shape of the nest sort of hold them in place as they hatch.
I use a method similar to the styrofoam holders that are mentioned in another thread. I use soft plastic foam strips that are used as insulation between glass blocks. They are 16" long, 3" wide, and 3/8" thick. I simply cut oval shapes into them with a utility knife and can fit 9 bantams or 7 LF on each strip. The eggs fit nicely on and into the grooves. The chicks hatch as close to natural as possible without any disturbance from the chicks. This plastic/foam is washable, flexible, reusable, and doesn't flake like styrofoam, so the chicks can't pick at it.
These strips are available at any Lowe's or Home Depot, and cost about a buck each. I am certain that I am getting as good a hatch as possible, and have no hatching dilemas. Here's a couple of pics of what they look like. Pick up a few and try them. Thank me later, lol.
[/img]