I don’t know how to build things but I’ll try anyway

There's a difference between a full foundation of mortared and rebar-reinforced blocks and using a few stacked blocks at strategic points to support an outbuilding. :)

We're talking about a chicken coop. Cinder block Pier 3 or 4 high without mortar will hold a chicken coop easily, if placed correctly.
 
We're talking about a chicken coop. Cinder block Pier 3 or 4 high without mortar will hold a chicken coop easily, if placed correctly.

Depends on what forces its intended to resist.

OP is building on a hill. If there is concern with soil movement downhill, or significant passage of water (I don't know slope on said hill, or peak rainfall amounts), dry stacked cinderblock is unlikely to address those issues. Similarly if there are wind uplift concerns (as in my climate).

Different situations, different solutions. Were it otherwise, we could all be civil engineers. ;)
 
My coops is made with 2x3 and osb as it is cheaper my coop is 4x8ft it works for me lol cant see the point in buying expensive materials for a chicken coop
This is my coop
FB_IMG_1643128923546.jpg
 
We're talking about a chicken coop. Cinder block Pier 3 or 4 high without mortar will hold a chicken coop easily, if placed correctly.

I come from a long line of over-engineers (my Dad figured anything that wasn't built to last 100 years was a temporary make-do), and married into a family of over-engineers. If there is a risk of failure that could be averted for a relatively small input of time and money I will recommend the input of that time and money. :)

My coops is made with 2x3 and osb as it is cheaper my coop is 4x8ft it works for me lol cant see the point in buying expensive materials for a chicken coop
This is my coop View attachment 2972141

OSB will not withstand a wet climate over time.

My Little Monitor Coop had one OSB wall after a miscut of the T-111 resulted in the need to use a scrap of what was on hand. It lasted less than a decade here in the Steamy Southeast despite paint and a good roof overhang.
 
Depends on what forces its intended to resist.

OP is building on a hill. If there is concern with soil movement downhill, or significant passage of water (I don't know slope on said hill, or peak rainfall amounts), dry stacked cinderblock is unlikely to address those issues. Similarly if there are wind uplift concerns (as in my climate).

Different situations, different solutions. Were it otherwise, we could all be civil engineers. ;)
Her idea of a hill might differ greatly from ours. Like to see a picture of the slop.

Your grasping at straws here with the " passage of water". Dry stacked or mortared cinder blocks, hollow or solid will fail if not done properly if water erosion is a problem.

Bottoms line is hollow cinder block will hold up a chicken coop ( and much larger) just as easily as solid blocks as long as either one is done properly.

Wish I had pics of our old houses basement. 4 dry stacked piers 5' high on a cement pad. Held the house up for 80+ yrs and counting.
 
I come from a long line of over-engineers (my Dad figured anything that wasn't built to last 100 years was a temporary make-do), and married into a family of over-engineers. If there is a risk of failure that could be averted for a relatively small input of time and money I will recommend the input of that time and money. :)



OSB will not withstand a wet climate over time.

My Little Monitor Coop had one OSB wall after a miscut of the T-111 resulted in the need to use a scrap of what was on hand. It lasted less than a decade here in the Steamy Southeast despite paint and a good roof overhang.
My oldest coop was made in 2015 and its still fine mine are painted I did have one coop that needed a new floor so had to redo that entire coop and now gonna need to lift it as its sinking into the ground. But id sooner replace walls etc then wasting $50 for a sheet of plywood my coop costed about $100 to make using other woods would be a couple hundred and unless my birds start getting jobs I will still use the cheapest wood :)
 
My oldest coop was made in 2015 and its still fine mine are painted I did have one coop that needed a new floor so had to redo that entire coop and now gonna need to lift it as its sinking into the ground. But id sooner replace walls etc then wasting $50 for a sheet of plywood my coop costed about $100 to make using other woods would be a couple hundred and unless my birds start getting jobs I will still use the cheapest wood :)

Climate matters.
 
Her idea of a hill might differ greatly from ours. Like to see a picture of the slop.

Your grasping at straws here with the " passage of water". Dry stacked or mortared cinder blocks, hollow or solid will fail if not done properly if water erosion is a problem.

Bottoms line is hollow cinder block will hold up a chicken coop ( and much larger) just as easily as solid blocks as long as either one is done properly.

Wish I had pics of our old houses basement. 4 dry stacked piers 5' high on a cement pad. Held the house up for 80+ yrs and counting.
I'm on a "hill" in FL. Only in FL would it be called a hill. Slope varies from near flat to a maximum of about 14 degrees. But I used to do (long, long ago) rainfall runoff calculations for Golf Courses in the "sunshine" state. You'd be surprised what water can do.

Agree, the details matter - which was part of my point. Just as drystacking on a concrete foundation is different than drystacking on soil...
 
nails are also less sturdy than screws, screws will allow a stronger coop then nails could
Screws have advantages primarily that they are removable much more easily than nails. Their easier removablity is somewhat offset by the time it takes to install vs using a power nailer.

However, they are not stronger than nails assuming we are comparing similar sizes. A screw has less shear strength (sideways as opposed to pull) and under some situations will break where a nail will not.

I do use screws for much of what I build except where strength matters (eg. framing).
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom