I would NEVER try and slam her because she's extremely nice, but I did get eggs from her about two years ago and they were not near that close to being dark. I'm wondering if those are maybe from new stock. Younger pullets I mean, than what I got? The ones I got were supposed to be for golden marans. I didn't have any luck hatching them, but they were really well packed and shipped quickly. She even sent me a second batch for free. I had a styrobator back then too..which is probably why they didn't hatch.
Just my 2-cents.
Stacy