Type, carriage: 12/40
Size, quality: 8/20
Colour, markings: 14/15
Head: 7/10
Condition: 9/10
Legs, feet: 2/5
—————————-
Total: 52/100
A healthy, well coloured pullet. Correct amount of copper of a great colour.
Frankly (sorry to be blunt), she looks like a really good marans was skinned and put over the body of a Welsummer.
By that I mean her type (build, body, frame and silhouette) is too lean and graceful. The tail is too long and high. A marans should be powerful, heavy and well muscled. They are, after all, a duel-purpose breed.
Your pullet looses out because of how much stress the marans standard (this is the standard presented by the UK marans club, as I know it best. The USA/Continental standards are very similar) puts on the correct type.
Her legs are also incorrect. They are well feathered and look healthy, but are all slate grey, like they have the slate legged gene (supported by the very black beak). Marans should have pink/white legs with only grey shading, which comes from the birchen gene.
Colour could be passed on and her line improved by breeding to a well built rooster.