No such thing as a perfect bird. He has so many good qualities tho.
As for mine, he’s growing on me. He’s got a great temperament and personality. I’ll see what he looks like before I decide to breed him and work on his defects.
White ear lobes are a recessive trait like any other defect in Marans, or any breed. While I wouldn't breed a bird with vulture hocks, the recessive genes are still there in some of my LA birds under the surface where you can't see, in their DNA. They don't exhibit vulture hocks, but some carry the gene and it crops up in their offspring. Apollo and #60 have produced 10% chicks exhibiting vulture hocks so far. Those chicks were culled, but the rest are looking good. As Chooks man says, if you cull all your chooks with flaws you won't have any chooks in your yard. There is no perfect bird. Only in paintings and our dreams. Even show winners have minor flaws. Hard culling is what builds a line, and we all have to start somewhere.