is either rooster worth keeping??

[Red&Yellow]

As lovely as they both are, I really advised against two roosters with five hens. Even if they don't fight, mating is pretty violent; if they are equal in mating rate, the hens would be pretty tired of it.

That said, I really love the first roo. He does look like golden cuckoo Marans... But you really should take the personality into consideration more than looks.

 

[ChickensAreSweet]

The first time we had chickens, we had one roo with 5 hens. There weren't enough hens for him, apparently, as the hens' backs started to get raw and feather-plucked.

So I would say, I recommend having more hens if you keep ONE rooster.

Edited because I remembered the TOTAL we had was 6.

 

[Judy]

Definitely choose one. Not fair to the hens to be mated by two of them -- one is often too much for only 3 hens, but you can judge that when you get it down to one.