Everybody loves homemade stuff at Christmas. I don't think anybody thinks about it being "cheap". I think your ideas are great. After we grew up and moved out of the house, my Mother used to make each of us a big plate of homemade Christmas cookies, all the ones we loved as kids when we were growing up. It was always one of my favorite presents. I was sad when she was no longer able to do that. She also made homemade Christmas tree ornaments, and so did my grandma and my aunt. My grandma and aunt made beautiful ones, I still have some of them, and my mother made Christmas spiders one year, there is a an old Christmas story about a silver spider in the Christmas tree, and that's what she was trying to represent. Just an inexpensive thing to make, but I love my spider, I put it on the tree every year , it's supposed to bring luck, and it reminds me of her; she died three years ago at Christmas time.