I am probably going to keep him, and see how it goes. Nothing about roosters being verboten here, tho we are skirting the lot size issue with all of the chickens. We're far enough apart from our neighbors that any early morning crowing should not be disturbing, as they will be locked in the coop at the back of our property. And the rooster on the street in back of us crows- loudly!- all day long and as far as I know, no one complains. He's been there a couple years now. We'll see. We've all become attached to this guy, and he's one of the tamest of the whole bunch right now.