Is this Immature of me or is this acceptable? Long but please read

[quail newbie]

Quote:
I'm not being snarky in saying this even though it might sound like it. That being said, I understand where you're coming from with reinforcing the pen but I also believe the dog owner has a responsibility to deal with the repercussions of their dog attacking someone's pets. If a child were to kill one of my birds I would hold the parent accountable at least making them replace said bird. She had said very clearly she did not want to kill the dog, it was only said to try to prevent a future attack.

I'm not trying to make anyone mad, just trying to get the point across

 

[Blackbird]

Quote:
Thats a good point, and its good to see another's point of view. I understand what you are saying, but I also see it like this; I can put my baked goods on the porch table, and it is possible that flies could get in it. But, you can also spray the area to prevent flies from going on the porch. It may not stop them, but it will help. Think of the spray as leash laws and similiar laws, they are there to protect people, land, and animals. It may not stop dogs from getting off, but it will help the owner to lagally dispose of the animal to protect their property & animals.

A dog may be a pet, but a chicken or quail can also be a dear pet.

 

[quail newbie]

Quote:
I'm sure if it was an issue traps would be set.

 

[mac80103]

I think you did your neighbor a favor by doing the research for him.
Just one thing you need to check into BEFORE you shoot a dog.....What I read on the PA law, specifies "domestic" animals and "household" pets. In some states, chickens are considered "livestock", so they may or not be covered.

Most important, is that you neighbor THINKS they are.

This makes me appreciate that our nearest neighbor is over a mile away!!

Good Luck!

 

[lavacaw]

Most (not all) law enforcement officers know the law. My suggestion is that you take what you have printed out to your local constabulary (sheriff or policeman) and ask them how they interpret it. If they say chickens are not livestock, that's the way they will probably interpret it if you shoot the dog. Also, I am assuming you live outside the city limits because in most places it is illegal to shoot a firearm within the city limits. Also, if you have to shoot it, shoot to kill! In some places you can be charged with animal cruelty for injuring an animal.

 

[birdbrain2]

Quote:
I'm sure if it was an issue traps would be set.

traps only get rid of one problem then more will move in. it sounds like your neighbors aren't the best, but like i said you must protect your chickens.
I am in know way siding with your neighbors. my neighbors dog attacked my chickens once and I beat the heck out of it when i caught it. but i then realized it was my own fault, my neighbors can be the nicest people, but its a given their dog will get out of the yard eventually, so i must protect my self.

 

[Blackbird]

Oh, I wanted to add, (not sure about chickens), but I'm pretty positive that Monarc doesn't free range her quail, and they're pretty protected from what her pictures show.

 

[birdbrain2]

Quote:
this is what i fear for you and anyone else with this issue.

 

[stuckinthecity]

OHHHHHH MY GOD
Im mad just reading that.
ENRAGED actaully.
What a....FREAK. for starters... I am so sorry you're bein put through this crap...
DEFF NOT IMMATURE. if anything they're the ones being immature.

 

[crazy cat lady]

Monarc I don't think you are being immature. you have warned your neighbor and time will tell if he understood your warning. I do think maybe you should call your law enforcement dept. and have them with you when/if you deliver the bylaws. I know you care very deeply about any animal, but you have to protect them from any and all preditors if at all possible.

Don't let this man get to you too much. Especially if you and your hubby are going to try have a little one. The stress is not good for you.

Take care hun! You have a lot of BYCers on your side.