First off give her a couple more days without eggs. She may decide that the broody thing is not for her yet!
Then if you give her eggs, the freshest is the best. Personally I would start gathering eggs now (or eggs gathered a couple of days ago at most) and give them to her in two days if she is still broody.
I agree with all of the above advice. I always let my girls sit on plastic eggs for a couple of days to make sure they are serious about being broody. Even then there are no guarantees!
Fresh eggs are definitely better than refrigerated eggs, but if you have no alternative I have heard of some people successfully hatching from fridge eggs before. Just let them come to room temperature before you put them under her! I used to start collecting eggs when I saw first saw my broody hen, and after 3 days would have a clutch to put under her. I used to just keep them in a basket in a cool-ish room in my house, and turn them over twice a day at morning and night.
I was looking forward to having a broody, but it happened sooner than we had anticipated and didn't have eggs/money/time to deal with the situation just then. So instead of letting her sit there for a month trying to hatch golf-balls, we decided to build a "breaker box". A few scrap 2x2s and some left-over hardware cloth, and voilla! 2 days in broody-jail and she was back to her old self (if a bit grumpy about the experience.)
![]()
Are you planning on letting the next broody hatch some eggs? I remember last time when you told us about the bird in question, and I was so disappointed for you. Hatching chicks, and then seeing the Momma Hen with her babies is amazing. I am starting to get really excited now - it's Day 20 and my broody is really anxious, clucking a lot, and looking between her legs. I think something is starting to happen!
Krista