Framac, I LOVE LOVE LOVE that black female!!! (the others are nice, too, but boy, that female...she's got it goin' on!)
John, I really am sorry that you're unhappy with what you have. I can't say, though, that this is not an unusual situation. Many of us have "been there, done that." I got hatching eggs from three different breeders and was dissatisfied with each & every one. I do keep one splash female as she's an excellent broody - worth her weight, and makes sense for me to feed her.
There are some excellent lines here in the Midwest - you say you're from Illionis? I'm not far from you, being in Michigan. There's also the district director, Tim Johnson, who is from Ohio. And a man by the name of Calhoun had VERY nice stock (and I belive won BB at Ohio Nationals this year) from OH.
Clearly, you're disappointed - I'm sorry you had to go through that with your chicks and I wish that no one ever had to, but unfortuantely, it happens...a lot. I would suggest selling off what you have - do you hatch? If so, choose someone on here who you like pictures of what you have seen in their stock, and order some eggs. If you do not hatch, then get to know some of us and hop in the car & take a drive - take a look at their stock in person, after asking for lots of photos...there is absolutely nothing like seeing them in person. All it takes is a good start - a good pair or trio to begin with, and you're off to the races!