I hope it is ok to join in. I have ordered eggs from others twice now and have had bad luck. I am so thrilled to hear good stories about ordering eggs and having them hatch. I use broodie hens and they can hatch out ones from my flock very well usualy they only lose like 2-3 in the whole nest. but when I order eggs they never do well. I have given up ordering eggs and will just stick with ones from my flock I guess. thank you for sharing all the good news it is so great to see good luck with hatching eggs... the pictures are so so cute...
I had terrible luck with shipped eggs before I ordered from Lucky Pickens. Then again, I'd only ordered serama eggs and those don't travel well at all. Both my orders from Roslyn took longer than expected to get to me (postal service's fault), but I had 7 develop and hatch the first time, and this time I've had 5 develop, and 1 quit last week. They're due to hatch next week. The one that quit had a pretty bad loose air cell, so I was surprised it started at all. A few of the eggs even looked like they had broken yolks... Don't know if that's even possible, but they were pretty messed up after USPS played with and lost them for a few days.
If you like bantam cochins you should try ordering from Roslyn (luckypickens). She's got heritage RIR and some other breeds in the egg auction as well. And she's so reasonable with her prices! She does a great job packing too. Hope you have better experiences coming your way!