Marans Thread - breed discussion & pictures are welcome!

Quote:
Yeah, what Ruth said! I would suppose if you knew where they were coming from that might be ok. But maybe folks are talking about picking up eggs from say a breeding PEN, as opposed to a one on one breeding set up? Just a thought. Your point does make sense though Ruth
wink.png


Most of those posting know which hens lay which eggs and in fact, comment that the same hens lays all the different shades but they only set the darkest ones. I guess that's the part I'm not sure makes any sense to me. If the mama lays every shade under the rainbow it's still the same chick and from what I would "assume" said chick would also lay every color under the rainbow and would not have any more propensity to only lay dark just because it came out of a dark egg.

On the other hand, if someone doesn't know which hen lays light eggs, they should. Separate each hen in a separate pen/kennel until it lays an egg, or two or three. Once you know she lays consistently dark eggs, keep her in the breeding program. If she only lays light eggs, kick her out.

In my experience, I'm not seeing a wide range of shades from the same hen. I have some that consistently lay very dark eggs. I know which ones are their eggs from a distance. By separating and then banding them, I know which hens are my darkest layers. So, if I were going to only set certain eggs, I would only set THEIR eggs, which are always dark eggs. Which, by the way, is another "project" I will undertake come Spring. I do have a couple that lay the very dark and sherical eggs so I guess I could start hatching just those eggs.
 
If you sit down and read in depth the genetics and such on this site many mysteries will be unravelled and the sister sites such as the marans club of begium and the marans club of australia... Keeping in mind that some of the genes for their different strains differ from ours but the goal is the same.
 
Even in Single mating...I set the darkest eggs... No real reason except that they look real cute when they hatch and you take thier pictures with thier shells... Important to log information for the roosters in particular as they lay no eggs later on as "proof"
 
So in keeping with the egg color in mind, does this mean all hens shown, will have to produce an egg?? Chasehope, I think it was, back a few pages, said the judge wouldn't judge her bird because she didn't have an egg. Like I said before, if this is the case, how could you prove that egg came from that hen, unless she laid it in the show cage?? Seems that would leave an awful lot of room for cheating.
 
There is a lot of room for cheating but who in the world would show a phenotype hen and pay the fees just to be a liar... (I am kinda niave here)
 
Geebs, ya just never know. I saw quite a bit of that kind of thing in the "dog world", what makes chicken folks any more different? People are people, and these days, the honor system seems to have taken a long hike. Not saying ALL folks would do this, nor am I pointing any fingers anywhere, it just leaves the door open to those who would take advantage of such a situation. JMHO
 
Quote:
Agreed. It all boils down to greed, IMO. Some people want to win ribbons in order to sell eggs to line their pockets.

That's what's a disgrace!
 
I thought I was going nuts on the #4 egg color thing... But Yep on Bev's site it is a #4 or better at some point during the cycle...

---
Agreed. It all boils down to greed, IMO. Some people want to win ribbons in order to sell eggs to line their pockets.

That's what's a disgrace!

Just so one does not think that showing and winning ribbons and selling the offspring is some sort of disgrace...
wink.png


I mean no line of Marans is perfect... If no one sold a bird until it was perfect their would be no birds....
lol.png


ON​
 
Quote:
Just so one does not think that showing and winning ribbons and selling the offspring is some sort of disgrace...
wink.png


I mean no line of Marans is perfect... If no one sold a bird until it was perfect their would be no birds....
lol.png


ON

Ditto.

Don - I'm befuddled as to why you are wondering about this, since you've made it clear you only set eggs that are a 6 or better...? Why do you only set eggs that are at least a 6...who did YOU hear the "#4 or better" from? Just curious!
 
Quote:
Just so one does not think that showing and winning ribbons and selling the offspring is some sort of disgrace...
wink.png


I mean no line of Marans is perfect... If no one sold a bird until it was perfect their would be no birds....
lol.png


ON

Ditto.

Don - I'm befuddled as to why you are wondering about this, since you've made it clear you only set eggs that are a 6 or better...? Why do you only set eggs that are at least a 6...who did YOU hear the "#4 or better" from? Just curious!

Wynette, I was trying to trace down the starting point for saying #4 or better, I believe you are the one that brought up the subject of the #4 egg. I thought it would be good if we all knew where the statement came from, and nothing else. Will worry about my own concerns in the future.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom