Well its officially one year since moving here to Wexford County from NC. We have several mutt chickens now. Barnevelder birds are a useless breed for us. The hens were horrible mothers and laid thin shelled eggs while all other hens who had the same diet had strong shells. Must have poor genes - will cull all but one soon. The "B" roosters worked out well when it came to parenting and managing the flock.
We made a mistake this year and ordered 20 partridge cochins from a hatchery. Henless (motherless) chicks are useless to our farm because they couldnt and still havent learned the daily game plan. These birds did not learn from the other adults. They are skinny so no meat and they are yet to lay an egg which should be here in mid November. I assume they will be broody often and perhaps good mothers by next spring.
We had several black jersey giants. They are an average sized bird (full grown/disappointing). They lay well and 50% of them were good mothers. The rest were negligent mothers that disowned their chicks before their chicks feathered out. I compare all mother skills to that of our bantam cochins which are phenomenal. Bantam cochins are the easiest chicken calendar and math to follow I've experienced to date. They are like clock work.
The best egg layers are the Ameraucana hands down (large and yummy) and the best meat birds (huge @ 16 weeks on non gmo scratch and insects) are the freedom rangers. The rangers are also the most pleasant - very friendly and gentle. Rangers will be the only chicken we buy next year. They run so funny - wobble wobble. If you allow a cochin chick to grow up with a predominant freedom ranger clutch the cochin will adopt the ranger's demeanor and habits. They'll even wobble slightly. Try it - fun. Even though they dont appear obsrvant and vigilant, they could at least least the flocks way of life unlike the partridge cochins.
We also integrated three peking ducks this summer. They are messy, loud and now frozen. We'll buy 10 more of those next year. Easy to heard, eat tons of bugs and weeds, and are easy to cull. Funny poultry. Perhaps eggs next year.
Well now all we have to endure is this winter that's coming. We built a 18 x 22 x 12 kick *** metal roof wind tight fortress / coop that has summer and winter runs. The winter run has a sloped green house roof. I'll post photos after deer season. Next years plan is to integrate two feeder pigs, 10 embden geese, 5 bronze turkeys, 10 jumbo peking, maintain our current layers (+ or - 40), and 25-30 freedom rangers. We'll donate a large % of our eggs to veteran homes and food pantries. Good luck!