Mixed reviews

[NewMama23]

I have posted other places and have received many mixed reviews. I am hoping they are ladies! These are 2 different chickens the second one has a tail with rounded feathers that curves toward its head. They are both 3 months old

 

[Sussex19]

First one is definitely a pullet, could you get another photo of the second one more straight from the side, rather then above?

 

[-Chanticleer-]

First one pullet second one is iffy. It has black feathers coming in around the neck and that’s a cockerel sign.

 

[Prince and Pavo]

Hello!

I believe that the first is a pullet and the second is a cockerel

 

[NewMama23]

First one is definitely a pullet, could you get another photo of the second one more straight from the side, rather then above?

I will get one this evening.

 

[NewMama23]

First one is definitely a pullet, could you get another photo of the second one more straight from the side, rather then above?

 

[Prince and Pavo]

View attachment 3544352

Probably a pullet. A cockerel’s comb and wattles would be bigger at this point

 

[NewMama23]

First one is definitely a pullet, could you get another photo of the second one more straight from the side, rather then above?

I should also add that both of these chickens are honking, not crowing.

 

[Sussex19]

View attachment 3544352

I think pullet. She has odd feathers, but I do not see any sign of a cockerel

 

[JedJackson]

They're both pullets. Weird tail feathers at a young age don't mean anything. Sickle feathers come in later on males.