I don’t know if ducks and chickens are different in this respect, but I pull eggs out from under wanna-be-broodies all the time. Then I put their butt in the broody breaker for a few days.
As of right now, I
do not want any broody ducks, cause I want
no new little ducklings. I am not 100% sure I want to add anymore ducks to my menagerie. However, I am still planning on fixing up a “nicer” duck area for the ones I have. It will be up to these five ducks to sell me on whether I want to continue to be a duck owner. They are
completely different than chickens. I think it’s the whole mating chaos that gets me...all of them going at it, almost constantly. The females don’t care that they aren’t male, they still go at it like they are. It leaves me speechless. I am hoping beyond hope that this “free love” behavior settles down after the ducks begin laying.
Oh, and one other thing I’ve noticed, they are
pushy little creatures. Every single animal on my property gets along so well, even my main man, Rusty the Roo. He feels no threat and thus doesn’t run at anything. I feel overly blessed because of this. My chickens grew up with all my other animals and will lay in the grass with all of the dogs and all of the cats. No worries! None of them are afraid of each other. (I’m speaking of my older flock, not the new chicks that are 12 weeks and less. They seem to be afraid of everything!)
Then add the ducks!

Good lord! They run everything off that even looks at them. Ralphie is the worst, but all of them do it. I’m just not used to that. It unnerves me to see the friction and chaos. I just want the peaceful and calm, the harmony of all my birds roaming the yard, together. That’s what I like about chicken keeping. To sit (or work) outside and see my birds peacefully roaming about the yard. That is my zen, or whatever it’s called. The ducks may change, I do not know. But if they don’t, I will have a choice: either to no longer keep ducks, or to make them their own duck yard and keep them separated. The latter is something I don’t want to do. I don't like confining any animal. Hopefully, the ducks will mature a bit more and join with the rest and live harmoniously. As I said earlier, it will be up to these five.
I’m sorry
@jaykayhuff, I know you didn’t ask for my semi-rant.