My original flock came with two roosters (one requested, the other an "oops") One of these guys was great until he hit 18 months, Then he started attacking other family members and my boarders. Then he started going after me. I found a new home for him right quick. The other rooster turned out to be the best rooster ever. He not only protected the hens, he would show the new pullets where to nest, how to nest and would even raise the chicks for me. When I got more roosters as my flock grew, he started to get picked on, so I moved him to the Nursery/Infirmary coop with a hen that would never quit being broody. The two of them raised many a group of hatchery chicks and helped injured hens recover in peace. He died last year at 10 years old. Mr. Feathers - best rooster ever.
Anyway, my view, is that aggressive roosters have no place on my farm. In the last few years, my flock grew to 60+ hens and I had 8 roosters. 5 were young flock-mates and they turned into a ##(^% gang (would actually break the pelvis bones of hens by over breeding, one after another!) I let a friend dispatch them and peace reigned. I currently have 96 chickens, and 8 roosters. And again, 5 of which are from the last incubated batch I had back in April. SO FAR, they're doing great. They've merged with my 3 older roosters (2-5 years old) and no one is ganging up on anyone. There is one iffy guy in the group, the bottom of the pecking order of Roosters, but the second he does something stupid, the hens squawk and all the other roosters run up and chase him off the poor girl.
A good rooster is worth his weight in gold. A bad rooster, no matter what your soft feelings for, is nothing but a hindrance, and even a threat to your flock. These guys I have now - I haven't had an aerial predator kill in 2 1/2 years now. They are awesome.
Anyway, my view, is that aggressive roosters have no place on my farm. In the last few years, my flock grew to 60+ hens and I had 8 roosters. 5 were young flock-mates and they turned into a ##(^% gang (would actually break the pelvis bones of hens by over breeding, one after another!) I let a friend dispatch them and peace reigned. I currently have 96 chickens, and 8 roosters. And again, 5 of which are from the last incubated batch I had back in April. SO FAR, they're doing great. They've merged with my 3 older roosters (2-5 years old) and no one is ganging up on anyone. There is one iffy guy in the group, the bottom of the pecking order of Roosters, but the second he does something stupid, the hens squawk and all the other roosters run up and chase him off the poor girl.
A good rooster is worth his weight in gold. A bad rooster, no matter what your soft feelings for, is nothing but a hindrance, and even a threat to your flock. These guys I have now - I haven't had an aerial predator kill in 2 1/2 years now. They are awesome.