Need help making a decision on which roo to keep

[tygab]

sir blue seems to be getting the popular vote... but for the two BLRWs I'd pick the one on the right...

I agree that Blue looks the most rooster of the four but I think the others may be younger still?

 

[tiki244]

You know which one you like

If you can keep them warm enough so the combs don't freeze, no problem. Looks like you have done well with the hens and their combs through the winter.