Long story short, my blackshoulder male got out cause I didn't latch the door all the way. It wandered into the neighbors yard and he shot and killed it. His son posted it on facebook which is how I found out. I called him out on it and he has offered to compensate me for it. In our conversation he complained about the noise and said that my free range India Blue has scratched his girlfriends car. His dog has come over here the last few years and has killed probably about a thousand dollars worth of chickens over the years but I overlooked it trying to be the good neighbor. I am at a loss of what to do. He has offered to compensate me but should I leave it at that. I hate to lose my birds due to his noise complaints. What would you do???