What do you mean the BW rooster chick from my eggs is not the right color? Could be he is out of the Cree pullets and these are their first offspring, so I have no idea what they will look like. I am finally keeping a couple of pullets out of them (I think- my two Smith hens are in that pen) for myself. I had a couple of extra chicks from an order I did and luckily they both turned out to be girls
I am also keeping two GCM pullets (sold all the rest I've hatched) that I hatched at the same time from the super dark eggs that have, that have not faded at all over their laying cycle. I am really surprised you got mostly GCM boys since I have consistently hatched more pullets from those eggs. Glad you got so many OE pullets though. Funny how the boys, but not girls got the feathered feet. How many W/BW Ameraucana pullets did you end up with?