Still love Suede. My chocolate boy has frostbitten comb points already. Suede was perfection.
So many have Blue Orps because I posted so many photos of Suede, sent out hundreds of hatching eggs back then. When I hatched out Suede and Velvet, Blue Orps were fairly rare on BYC. Later, when more came along, a certain group of folks were highly critical of his faults, and he did have them, certainly. His eyes were too light, should have been dark brown, but his hens had dark brown eyes and most of the progeny did. He also carried a hidden yellow leg gene from the influx of Rock by Sandhill Preservation many generations back, plus, he also, if you look closely at his sickle feathers, has some barring. On rare occasion, a chick would have yellow legs. Suede's were slate, his hens had proper slate legs, but the gene was in his lineage.
Once, he and Meg, my RIR x Buff Orp hen produced a completely barred chick. No fence jumping by a BR rooster, no way it could have happened without bloodshed here, and it was the
only Meg egg in a bunch of blue eggs. So, we were perplexed by the barred chick until we began to look at Suede more closely and saw the light blue/dark blue in his sickle feathers.
Anyway, then, on top of that, came the newest rage at that time, the "English" Orpingtons, the imports. Of course, all Orpingtons are English, but the new and, to me, Cochin-like, too fluffy Orps were not very appealing. Plus, they were too large for the standard, even larger than Suede. There was a small group on BYC who literally told me that I could not
not like them, that they were perfect. Yes, they really did tell me that. I said I surely
can have my preferences! I prefer the "normal" Orpingtons, all Orps are an English breed, of course, and that fluff to the ground looked Cochin-y to me. And I was pooh-poohed about that remark and more Suede-bashing. I never said he did not have flaws, not for one moment, but the attitude that I could not even have my own preference was ridiculous. I was not one of the "cool kids" then, LOL. Good grief, it was so dumb! Everyone can have their own preferences in chickens, for cripes sake! I rather like the ones that are not 100% import type still, the crosses like Ladyhawk's hen, Mary Todd, who is still a hunka-chunka hen. She probably weighs over 11 lbs even being only 1/2 import Orp.