We have a duplex we rent out 3 hours from here. (Gawd, how I want to sell the place) I just spent this past weekend there. Not a HUGE amount of damage, just stupid things like holes in doors and grease EVERYWHERE from cooking. However they stole EVERY appliance in the place. GRRRR.... Not only are people pigs but in today's economy they are theives too.
We are going to take them to court. Probably won't get anything except the satisfaction of seeing their name published in the paper as having a judgement against them, but really....THE APPLIANCES? Move out and take things that don't belong to you? Now That is low low low.
I recently have been to a friends rental which I must say they haven't been watching. All the copper was stolen. They didn't and don't know how to deal with things. The place is neglected at best and a dump at worst. They are looking to unload the place so I think.
My SIL and I went over and repaired the front steps which had been busted up by a neighbors car and a support under the side porch. They had a jack under it but that got stolen.
Here's my advice as a former letter carrier. If you decide to rent again, get their old address or even addresses. Then go and talk to the mailman. The mailman not only knows where they live but HOW they live. He's sees their mail and knows more than you think. He can tell you how long they've really lived there and any problems.
My aunt used to say she had four kids but she really had eight. One lady I delivered to had the utility bill in her little daughters name. I suspect she owed in her own and stole her daughters social security number.
The mailman can tell you if they are really married or just shacking and for how long. Whose kids are whose.
Never, never , never expect to rent it and forget it. If you need to, pick up the rent at the house so you can see what's happening. Do a drive by on weekends. While you might get more money with Section 8, you may get more problems too. Seems to me it might be better to rent for less to working folks, than not.
Remember every house will sustain the usual wear and tear. A busted window or broken faucet are not damage. Life happens to them and us. Maintenance is your responsibility. We had one landlord who wouldn't fix a leaky toilet even after I bought the seal to do it. We made lots of mistakes like doing the painting ourselves for no compensation.
I wish you well,
Rancher