Ugh.. Well, the one baby, two mamas thing did NOT work out. I am having the worst luck this year. I think I have a cannibal chicken and not sure who it is. Probably the white leghorn who squashed the babies. I never separate my moms and babies and they do fine every year but not this one!
Problem is, no room for separation. My one chick with two mamas was found pecked to death today and mamas are still wandering around clucking and finding food for it. Argh! I have chicks today, but I don't know if they will accept them. Going to have to ponder on this one a bit, I think, as there's no room to put broodies and chicks separate. Hmm.
ETA: Ok, I made room in the barn. Put two nestboxes I got from javagirl in there, food and water and a chicken wire separator. now time to play musical chickens.. broodies in the barn, teens move to the coops next week, etc. Only my good broodies get a barn spot

. Let's see if that works.
Going to put two hens sitting on eggs (together) in the barn. Anyone think the two broodies who lost a days old chick would take a younger one? or will they not accept anything but 'that baby' since they had already started taking it around outside?