Update already. I think I know who the egg eater is. I was out there and one was inside the nest box. I went inside and made another box hopeing it was just crowding. when I went back out no egg in the box the chicken was in. as i'm working one comes into the coop gets in the box and starts digging around. I added more hay and though maybe she's looking for something in it. well I get the other nest box installed put hay in it put her in it and she pecks at the back. I sit there for a bit then she gets in the other nest box where they been laying and starts pokeing around in back of box where they eggs are then starts poking the plastic egg so I marked her with blue kote. Now to find out how to break a chicken from eating eggs.
So far from googleing I've seen golf balls left in box. collect eggs all day. Use a tac to break an egg hole, empty the egg, then fill with mustard. One said line bottom of box with plastic looks like they used astro turf or something.
really don't want to cull one of my reds already when they are just starting to lay.
jlaw