There is no great mystery to dry incubation. You simply don't add water. It's not a new person vs. experienced person thing. It's a fairly simple concept. Anyone can do it.
In a place where the ambient humidity stays relatively high, there is less need to constantly maintain water in the incubators because the air in and around the incubator has plenty of water in it. Places like where I live, in KY or other parts of the south, this works very well.
However, if you live say in Arizona, you would still need to add water from 1-18 because the ambient humidity is practically non-existent.
I still maintain a hygrometer in my incubators - I use Styrofoam ones btw - and my humidity with out water fluctuates some but usually ranges in the 30% level. This is more than adequate amount of humidity during the incubation part of the process.
The caveat here would be if you use a cabinet incubator that seals more readily, the ambient humidity may not be as much of a factor and thus water may be necessary to add.
Where people get into trouble is when they get up over that and especially into the 50 and 60% ranges during the first 18 days.
Again, this is why I say geographical location, time of year (summer has more humidity than winter here.) and type of incubator are very relevant to how you maintain your humidity.
Further, some people prefer hatching without water, some people want to hatch with, some people like low maintenance and some people are full on worry warts. How you hatch is your own personal preference and finding what works best for you and your location.
The "advice" I have given in this or any other thread is based solely on my trial and error process and I have found that with the kind of incubators I use and the place where I live, this is the method that works best for me and produces the best hatch rates.
What anyone chooses to do is their business. It doesn't make it right or wrong.
In a place where the ambient humidity stays relatively high, there is less need to constantly maintain water in the incubators because the air in and around the incubator has plenty of water in it. Places like where I live, in KY or other parts of the south, this works very well.
However, if you live say in Arizona, you would still need to add water from 1-18 because the ambient humidity is practically non-existent.
I still maintain a hygrometer in my incubators - I use Styrofoam ones btw - and my humidity with out water fluctuates some but usually ranges in the 30% level. This is more than adequate amount of humidity during the incubation part of the process.
The caveat here would be if you use a cabinet incubator that seals more readily, the ambient humidity may not be as much of a factor and thus water may be necessary to add.
Where people get into trouble is when they get up over that and especially into the 50 and 60% ranges during the first 18 days.
Again, this is why I say geographical location, time of year (summer has more humidity than winter here.) and type of incubator are very relevant to how you maintain your humidity.
Further, some people prefer hatching without water, some people want to hatch with, some people like low maintenance and some people are full on worry warts. How you hatch is your own personal preference and finding what works best for you and your location.
The "advice" I have given in this or any other thread is based solely on my trial and error process and I have found that with the kind of incubators I use and the place where I live, this is the method that works best for me and produces the best hatch rates.
What anyone chooses to do is their business. It doesn't make it right or wrong.