Carla, your packing job is superb. There story has changed enough to give me pause. They said the box was fine in one reply you posted an in another the photos showed it damaged? If you are unsure what to do at the most I would send the difrence of 6 eggs if and ONLY if they payed the shipping. However when people start threating me I dont tend to bend. Let them post a photo an get tore apart on here. Ive had great luck with shipped eggs and Ive had the poops with them. It was NOT your packing (or your husbands?) skills that broke those eggs. You cannot be responsible for the PO playing kickball with the box and hacky sack with the eggs.