I also have 6 from one duck (Dark Wader) 2 weeks old and so far 5 from today from Nanni. She still sits on some eggs. The reason for the low hatch rate of the trio is mainly they are the worst mothers ever. I don't know how often I had to save the duckies. After one hatched they pretty much decided that's enough. However they did stay on the eggs until they had one each. After that they got really careless.
I don't know if I have enough posts to post pictures. Plus I don't know yet how. I'll check it out. They seem to grow faster than the ones I had in the brooder last year.
So yes, I think with the right ducks co-parenting can work. I believe that only the fact that they have three mothers each even made survival for these 3 possible.
Gracie that is the main broody is drake size and oh so (insert major expletives here) determined. ChocoDuck is the runt of the four but the loudest most pushy duck determined to assist in the brooding. Houdini would be the one that went all goofy and "hey little ducks what a surprise let's go swimming - why aren't you moving?" - she's the blond joke punchline of the flock. I trust my drake with the ducklings more than her. Part of my quandary in this adventure.
I am new too and I haven't been moderated for posting pictures but my posts were held when I posted too many links in a row. When you do a reply, the box that has the smiley face, the first icon is a link to post pictures. You can upload them directly from your computer.
I believe I have a good parenting cluster, I feel they will do better together. If someone pipes up and says they have never seen this situation work in x years of experience, I will totally rethink those thoughts. In hindsight I think I got all stressed not so much with the hatch/non-hatch but with the quiet. They're Ancona's, they aren't loud but they always have this undercurrent of babble, and it's gone. Nothing feels right when they are so quiet, makes me edgy.