exactly. A VERY good broody will protect her chicks from anything or anyone who moves too fast, gets too close etc.That doesn't mean one who will stand on you or let her chicks stand on you isn't good. I have one broody who lets me walk right up to her and her chicks. She will run over my feet to get food. She is the exception to my broody's however, not the rule.I'm certain no one is saying 'don't have a broody who isn't mean' what is being said is being mean and grouchy and attacking you is kinda normal for a broody...that makes her a good one, not bad....she is protecting those chicks. Now hens that are very used to you may not attack you, animals certainly can be conditioned. My chickens are used to the dogs, but I can tell with my eyes closed when a dog is close to the hen house....everybody gets nervous...as they should. But I'm sure they would go after the dog given the chance....
They are chickens with chicken reactions. It is nature and like people they are all different.
I think I'm taking a vacation from this thread. anyone needs me pm me. I'm burned out............