i guess it's time for a family meeting!! at this point i see no harm keeping them all but i hope they don't "damage" fluffy. they don't even acknowledge her right now but what happens when...
I don't see a problem with you keeping them all if they were raised together. Fluffy may see a problem though,lol. I would not give up hope that you may have another hen there somewhere ( I don't think you do) but I could be wrong. Get those boy's somemore girls and you will have a happy flock!!
Big Mama is definitely a cockerel. Pointy saddle and sickle feathers in that tail. Chick and Scrappy look like male red sex-links. How old are these birds?
Definately Scrappy is a boy look at those spur knubs!!!! Chick and Fluffy look like hens. If it crows it is a boy, hens don't crow ever!
Check for spur knubs that barely stick out. We got hoodwiinked and told we were buying pairs of chickens and all we got were roos every danged one of them.
People know what they are doing and don't let them tell you otherwise. I believe in telling it like it is. So many kids get hurt
by people that lie to them about what they are buying. They might buy the roos anyway but lordie don't lie to them.